With a hard-fought season for all the girl’s basketball teams in the Rolling Valley Conference, the conference released the All-Conference selections for the 2023-24 season. Listed below are the first and second-team selections with their school and grade. The * indicates a unanimous selection by the conference.
First-Team All-Rolling Valley Conference
| Player | School | Grade |
| Breeley Clayburg* | Coon Rapids-Bayard | Sr. |
| Eva Steffensen* | CAM | Sr. |
| Taryn Petersen* | Exira-EHK | Fr. |
| Jaelynn Petersen* | Exira-EHK | So. |
| Charlie Pryor* | Woodbine | Jr. |
| Malia Clayburg | Coon Rapids-Bayard | So. |
| Kiera Nichols | CAM | Sr. |
| Nicole Hoefer | Woodbine | Sr. |
Second-Team All-Rolling Valley Conference
| Player | School | Grade |
| Anna Hart | Coon Rapids-Bayard | So. |
| Meredith Rich | CAM | Sr. |
| Delaney Schurke | Ar-We-Va | Sr. |
| DJ Steinkuehler | Woodbine | Jr. |
| Amanda Newton | Woodbine | Sr. |
| Sylvia Sullivan | Boyer Valley | So. |
| Maclayn Houston | West Harrison | Sr. |
| Tiela Janssen | Glidden-Ralston | Sr. |
